The neighborhood where Nancy Guthrie went missing has breathtaking views of the Santa Catalina mountains and strict limits on outdoor lighting to protect Tucson's standing as a stargazer's paradise. The streets of the Catalina Foothills are lined with Arizona's iconic, giant three-armed Saguaro cacti – and throngs of journalists, investigators, and neighbors are fixated on the disappearance of Savannah Guthrie's mother, Nancy.

It's unbelievable. This just doesn't happen here, said Susan Crosson, who lives around the corner from Nancy but does not know the family.

We're shocked, she added. We're locking our doors.

A security guard patrols the Guthrie house, keeping media and amateur sleuths from coming too close. Outside, a sign reads: Dear Guthrie Family, your neighbors stand with you. Laura Gargano, a neighbor, shared how residents are beefing up their security since the disappearance.

Officers believe Nancy was taken from her home against her will at around 02:30am on February 1st. There were signs of forced entry, a security camera had been removed, and police found blood that has now been identified as belonging to Nancy.

As the community rallies in support through candlelight vigils, local churches express their love for Nancy, providing an emotional backdrop to this unsettling event. The investigation into her disappearance continues, with police looking into ransom notes that may have been sent related to the case, indicating the seriousness of the crime and leaving residents anxious yet hopeful for Nancy's safe return.