Skip to main content
EcoSphere News

Prominent Gaza Scholar Denounces Hamas Attack in Historic Fatwa

Professor Dr Salman al-Dayah issues a pivotal fatwa condemning the actions of Hamas, emphasizing the need for ethical conduct in jihad and highlighting the unintended consequences of the October 7 attack.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Prominent Gaza Scholar Denounces Hamas Attack in Historic Fatwa
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

The esteemed Islamic scholar, Dr Salman al-Dayah, criticizes the October 7 Hamas attack on Israel in a significant fatwa, urging adherence to Islamic principles in warfare and expressing concern over the resulting humanitarian crisis in Gaza.

In a groundbreaking fatwa, Professor Dr Salman al-Dayah, one of Gaza's most respected Islamic scholars, has publicly denounced the Hamas attack on Israel that took place on October 7, 2023, a move that has significantly escalated the ongoing conflict in the region. A former dean of the Faculty of Sharia and Law at the Islamic University of Gaza, Dr Dayah's legal opinions resonate strongly with Gaza's predominantly Sunni Muslim population of about two million.Fatwas, which are non-binding legal rulings issued by recognized religious authorities, hold considerable weight in the Muslim community. Dr Dayah's six-page document characterizes the assault as a violation of Islamic principles governing the concept of jihad. He highlights the term “jihad,” defining it as both a personal and a collective struggle, but stresses that if the essential conditions for legitimate warfare are not satisfied, such actions must be avoided to prevent needless suffering.Dr Dayah emphasizes that the consequences of the October attack, which resulted in over 1,200 deaths and numerous civilian casualties due to subsequent Israeli military actions, starkly contradict Islamic teachings. He implores that it is critical for leaders, including those in Hamas, to ensure that military actions do not provoke disproportionate responses that could endanger innocent lives.By invoking Quranic teachings and prophetic traditions, Dr Dayah asserts that jihad must avoid harming civilians and that leaders must safeguard their well-being. “Human life is more precious to God than Mecca,” he boldly states, highlighting the moral imperative in Islamic tradition to protect non-combatants.His critique poses a serious challenge to Hamas, which often draws on religious justification for its military actions. The fatwa also sheds light on the increasing internal discourse within Gaza and the wider Arab world questioning the ethics of armed resistance.Dr Dayah's moderate Salafist beliefs place him at odds with Hamas’s approach, as he advocates for an Islamic governance model rooted in the principles of Islamic law rather than partisan politics. His unwavering commitment to his religious duties is reflected in his choice to remain in Gaza, even amidst the chaos, to provide his legal insight during this tumultuous period.The reaction to this fatwa could potentially deepen the divisions within Palestinian society regarding the strategies employed in the ongoing conflict with Israel. Sheikh Ashraf Ahmed, an admirer and student of Dr Dayah, noted that his legal judgment resonates powerfully in this historical moment.As the impact of this fatwa reverberates throughout Gaza and beyond, it serves as a crucial reminder of the ethical considerations at the heart of religious and political conflicts, challenging both politicians and citizens to reflect on the implications of their actions in the ongoing struggle for peace in the region.

Topics

More on this story