In brief
This week, the annual Christmas tree auction in Mifflinburg, Pennsylvania, attracted buyers across the Northeast, highlighting a vibrant market for natural holiday décor. While artificial trees are becoming more popular, a significant number of shoppers still seek the authentic experience of a real Christmas tree, driven by nostalgia and scent. The auction emphasizes quality and local sourcing, marking a hopeful season for traditional tree growers.
MIFFLINBURG, Pa. — In a bustling event this week in Pennsylvania, Christmas trees took center stage at the Buffalo Valley Produce Auction, attracting a multitude of eager buyers. Approximately 50,000 fresh Christmas trees, along with wreaths and a variety of holiday decorations, were sold in a two-day auction that filled an entire airplane hangar.
Garden stores and retail outlets from across the Northeast and mid-Atlantic region gathered to stock up for the upcoming holiday season, with the Fraser fir standing out as the favored choice among consumers.
Despite brisk temperatures, bidders braved the cold to secure everything from ornaments to icicle lights and tree stands. Notably absent were food items and gifts, but the rich scent of pine hinted at the festive spirit that soon will envelop homes across the region.
Marsha Gray of the Real Christmas Tree Board noted that consumer habits have shifted over the years. There’s a declining trend in households displaying Christmas trees, with many opting for artificial alternatives. Yet, the nostalgia and sensory appeal of a real tree remain strong motivations for purchases.
Cory Stephens, returning for a second consecutive year, emphasized the quality of products available. He invested nearly $5,000 for his store, A.A. Co. Farm, Lawn & Garden, driven by positive customer feedback from previous years. “It’s incredible, it’s changed our whole world,” he said.
Ryan Marshall from Ward’s Berry Farm similarly made a substantial investment, buying $8,000 worth of decorations and expecting to double his return.
Gray's research indicates that most buyers are drawn to the natural scent of real trees, with families often favoring farm-grown options. Auctions like Buffalo Valley illustrate a hopeful stabilization of prices for natural trees, which offers a chance to regain momentum against artificial sales. “The live tree puts the real Christmas in your house,” stated auction manager Neil Courtney.
With reports indicating over 21 million farm-grown Christmas tree sales in 2023 and median prices holding steady, the allure of a real Christmas tree continues to endure. As the season unfolds, many hope the trend towards artificial trees will reverse, reaffirming the cherished tradition of the holiday season.

