According to sources, this new guideline restricts the State Department's commentary to “rare” occasions, departing from a historical precedent where the U.S. would actively denounce fraudulent, coercive, or otherwise unjust elections. Diplomats traditionally viewed these critiques as essential for placing pressure on unethical regimes and supporting democratic movements. Previous administrations, including Joe Biden’s, had actively called out issues of political malpractice in various nations, such as Nicaragua and Belarus.

The memo's implications could effectively mute U.S. critiques aimed at corrupt electoral systems and impact the country’s moral authority on global democratic practices. As the Biden administration had focused on vocalizing concerns about undemocratic actions, Rubio's directive raises alarms about the U.S.'s commitment to fostering democratic values abroad and how it may influence international relations moving forward.