Utah Judge Orders Release of Closed Hearing Transcripts in High-Profile Case

Mon Dec 29 2025 23:10:07 GMT+0200 (Eastern European Standard Time)

A Utah judge has mandated the release of transcripts and audio recordings from a closed hearing regarding the restraints of a man charged with the murder of a conservative activist. The court's emphasis on transparency highlights the judicial system's commitment to public accountability.

A Utah judge has ordered the release of transcripts and audio recordings from a closed hearing about the case of Tyler Robinson, who is charged with the murder of conservative activist Charlie Kirk. The judge emphasized the importance of public transparency while allowing for minor redactions. Robinson, facing aggravated murder charges, will be restrained during court proceedings to ensure courtroom safety. The preliminary hearing is set for May 18.

A Utah judge on Monday ordered the release of transcripts from a closed-door hearing in October regarding whether Tyler Robinson, who is charged with the murder of Charlie Kirk, must be shackled during court proceedings.

State District Judge Tony Graf responded to press requests for transparency and stated that the transcripts need to be available on the court docket by the day's end. The request for disclosure came from media attorneys advocating for the public's right to information surrounding legal proceedings.

Robinson has been charged with aggravated murder in relation to the September shooting of conservative activist Charlie Kirk on Utah Valley University's campus. Prosecutors have indicated their intent to seek the death penalty against him.

In early October, Robinson's defense attorneys requested that their client be allowed to appear in court without restraints, arguing that it could create bias among the jurors. However, Judge Graf ultimately decided that while Robinson could appear in civilian clothing, he would still be required to wear restraints to ensure safety in the courtroom.

Graf's decision came after he determined that restraints would protect both court staff and Robinson himself, allowing for swift action should any disruptions occur during proceedings. In accordance with Utah court rules, defendants held in custody are typically restrained unless otherwise specified.

Judge Graf stressed that public transparency is a foundational aspect of the judicial system. His ruling included minor redactions to discussions about security protocols relevant to the high-profile case. Both a transcript and an audio recording of the hearing are slated for release, ensuring public access while maintaining necessary confidentiality concerning certain details.

The media lawyers had emphasized that an open court is critical for safeguarding the integrity of the fact-finding process and maintaining public trust in judicial fairness. Criminal trials in the United States have a longstanding tradition of being open to the public, highlighting the notion that fair trials can occur without limiting reporters’ access.

While Robinson did not physically attend the court session on Monday, he participated via audio link from the Utah County Jail. A preliminary hearing, where prosecutors are expected to detail their case against him, is slated for the week of May 18.