Pope Francis, who passed away on April 22, 2025, left behind a legacy marked by both sorrow and speculation in Argentina, particularly concerning his lack of visits to his homeland. While his papacy spanned 12 years and included engagements with many countries, his absence has led to questions regarding political implications and personal choices.
Reflecting on Pope Francis' Absence: A Mixed Legacy in Argentina
Reflecting on Pope Francis' Absence: A Mixed Legacy in Argentina
As Argentina mourns the passing of Pope Francis, unresolved feelings linger over his choice not to return home during his papacy.
As Argentinians gather to grieve the death of Pope Francis, a palpable sense of melancholy looms over the nation, accented by a haunting question: why did their native son never set foot in Argentina during his 12-year papacy? Laura Aguirre, a local bakery cashier, expressed a common sentiment after attending a Mass in tribute to the beloved pontiff. “Honestly, I didn’t like that he never came to Argentina,” she said, standing outside the Basílica de San José de Flores, a significant site close to Francis's childhood home.
Many speculate that the pope's avoidance of his homeland stemmed from a wish to steer clear of political entanglements. “He didn’t want any president to wrap themselves in his cloak, saying, ‘I’m the one who brought the pope,’” explained Sebastián Morales, reflecting on the complex dynamics between Francis and Argentina's political leaders.
The late pope’s relationship with Argentine presidents was often fraught, rooted in personal and ideological differences. While he clashed with former President Cristina Fernández de Kirchner over matters such as the legalization of same-sex marriage, they later reconciled. However, his disapproval of policies from another president, Mauricio Macri, was evident, and he adamantly opposed the 2020 abortion legislation introduced by President Alberto Fernández.
Recent comments by current president Javier Milei, who once referred to Francis as an “imbecile” due to his advocacy for social justice, punctuated the pontiff's tense political landscape. Although Milei has since apologized and met with Francis at the Vatican last year, many question what might have altered had Francis chosen to return home.
As Argentina prepares to bid farewell to him at his funeral, the mix of admiration and regret captures the essence of a nation reflecting on his legacy—a theme of social justice deeply woven into his teachings, but marked by an undeniable absence that many can’t help but wonder about.
